Why Everyone Freaked Out Over The Citrus Anime (Including Me)

Last year, the words echoed throughout the anime community: “CITRUS IS GETTING AN ANIME.” And finally, this past season (Winter 2018), the dream finally became a reality. Citrus officially premiered as an anime! During its run, both positive and negative reviews of the show popped up everywhere. Yuri fans screamed victory while others weren’t so impressed. But why?

The answer is, simply, because Citrus is a wonderfully gay, very controversial yuri anime.

Note: If you aren’t already aware, I am a queer girl 🙂

Citrus Anime Key Visual

The Problem With Yuri Anime

A couple months back, I wrote a piece about validating lesbian relationships in Japan and in anime. You can read the entire post here, but basically, lesbian relationships aren’t usually seen as real in Japanese culture. They aren’t considered bad per say, but they aren’t considered legitimate either.

Because of this belief, past yuri anime hasn’t exactly been popular, at least in the mainstream. It has existed for a long time, but it’s always been underground. Yuri manga, on the other hand, has much more content, but is extremely niche. You won’t find obscure yuri manga unless you go looking for it. To make things worse, yuri anime haven’t always been super successful. Strawberry Panic and Kannazuki No Miko were popular for a while, but they aired over ten years ago and have fallen under the radar, except for in the yuri community.

Kannazuki No Miko

Recently, there have been some yuri anime that have been good, whiles others… weren’t so much. Valkyrie Drive Mermaid had “yuri,” but was pretty much just a giant fan service fest with absolutely no plot. I couldn’t even finish it. I honestly found it insulting. There was also Sakura Trick, which I really enjoyed. It was so cute, and the yuri seemed legitimate. But it aired late at night in Japan and didn’t get the best reception here (except for hardcore yuri fans like myself).  And let’s not forget Yuri Kuma Arashi, which is one of my favorite shows of all time. It’s yuri was brash and bold, but many people couldn’t relate to its abstract and bizarre storytelling.

Then, there are light yuri shows that will have yuri elements, where a female character obviously likes another girl. The problem in these shows is that the yuri never really goes anywhere, stays in the background, or is just used for comedy. In my opinion, most of these shows aren’t bad- some of them are actually favorites of mine, like Kin Iro Mosaic.

Yuri Kuma Arashi.png

But after you’ve watched so many shows with these elements, it gets very, very frustrating. You want to see the girls actually form meaningful romantic relationships. You want their sexuality to be validated and accepted. But it just doesn’t happen most of the time in anime.

Positives About Citrus

Citrus Doesn’t Follow The Same Trend

Citrus is different. This anime doesn’t pull any punches when it comes to yuri. Almost right away, the main character Yuzu realizes that she has feelings for another girl named Mei (she’s actually Yuzu’s step-sister, but more about that later). She has some doubts at first, but they never stop her from pursuing Mei as the show progresses.

And honestly, Yuzu is super gay. So gay, in fact, it is refreshing and relatable. I know what it is like to have feelings for another girl when you are a teenager. Other than the step-sister thing, Yuzu’s experience echoes my own, and I am sure it is similar to other queer female’s. Being a gay teenage girl is very messy and confusing, and, of course, things get even messier when the girl you like has to come to terms with her own sexuality.  Sometimes it is easy, like with me and my fiance- by the time we met, we were a little older and both completely comfortable with our sexuality. But many times, it just becomes chaos.

Citrus Anime Yuzu Embarassed.png

Yuzu and Mei flit around their feelings for each other throughout the show, but Yuzu never fully gives up. She keeps pursuing Mei, which is super important. It illustrates that she isn’t letting society’s expectations or cultural norms stop her from loving who she loves: a girl. Occasionally, character’s in Citrus made comments about how weird it is for two girls to be together, but it happens a lot less than other shows. And Yuzu doesn’t constantly deny her sexuality the way some gay characters do.

It’s extremely refreshing. It tells the audience that it’s okay to for a girl to chase after another girl. And it’s even more refreshing that eventually Yuzu and Mei admit their feelings for each other and start dating. They kiss, hold hands, and consider themselves in a relationship. For the yuri community, which is starved for content, this is a miracle. It is golden. It is un-apologetically gay. It’s why yuri fans were so happy when the anime was announced and as it aired.

We freaked out before in anticipation. We freaked out during the season because they did an amazing job with the anime. And finally, we freaked out afterward because they ended the show in the best way possible. They gave us what we wanted: more moments of Yuzu and Mei together. Lita’s review of the final episode sums up a lot of the feelings I (and I am sure many others had about Yuzu and Mei.

Citrus Anime Yuzu and Mei Kiss

Why Citrus Received More Attention Than Other Yuri

The series was praised because of everything I just mentioned, but it is a little more complex than that. In my opinion, it was so hyped because of the Citrus manga and the internet. Like most manga, the Citrus manga got a fan-made translation that can be read online for free. There are a lot of mixed views on this topic… but personally, I think online manga is a good thing because it will expose more people to different series. As long as you eventually buy the manga, the artist won’t suffer.

Anyway,the Citrus manga began being uploaded online and news spread quickly. It became popular fast in the yuri community because of the reasons I explained. Many fell in love with Yuzu, Mei, their story, and their legitimate gayness. After a while, American publishers caught on to the hype and Seven Seas began publishing the manga in English. The first volume quickly became a New York Times bestseller. With Citrus all over the internet and now in major book stores like Barnes & Noble, awareness about the series grew and grew.

And why’s the anime adaption received so much attention: the series already had a huge fan base.

English Citrus Manga Cover

Negatives About Citrus

Step-Sisters In Love

Although me and many other people are fans of Citrus, the series does have its flaws. A lot of flaws and a lot of controversy. Namely, there is the whole step-sister thing. Normally, I don’t condone incest, even if it isn’t blood-related. However, Citrus doesn’t have the typical situation where the sisters/brother/whoever have grown up together and were raised as sibling.

Yuzu and Mei are literally two hormonal teenage girls that are forced to live together. They know nothing about each other and yet are expected to instantly act “like sisters.” In most cases, especially in real life, this doesn’t happen easily. Many times, re-marriages are sloppy and create tension between new siblings. This happened in Citrus, except it was sexual tension haha.

Yuzu and Mei Step-Sisters

However, I do understand if the whole sister thing is off-putting. But I just want to emphasize that it isn’t like other incest-laden anime (like Ero-Manga Sensei) and it isn’t just lip service. Incest isn’t the whole point of the series. The step-sister situation creates the following situation: two girls thrown together into an uncomfortable situation where they need to figure out their feelings for each other. Think about it- if you had to spend almost every waking moment with the person you like, it is going to create tension. And if you and that person already have a strained relationship, it will create even more tension. Basically, it creates the drama bomb that Citrus is.

If you can look past the step-sister thing, I think you could enjoy the show. But please don’t assume the show is automatically trash because of the sister scenario, unlike this article (which frankly pissed me off).

Elements of Sexual Assault

Note: Before I go into this section, I want to say that Citrus was created by a woman. Yes, it has sexual themes, but it wasn’t “written by men for men.” And again, I am a girl.

The more unforgiving aspect of Citrus is its tendency to emphasize sexual assault. In the very first episode, Mei forces down Yuzu and kisses her. The anime community was not happy about this. I admit I was a little taken aback- I don’t remember that scene being quite so violent or drawn out in the manga. I am not sure why they heightened that scene- it might be an attempt to make things more dramatic or trashier, to cater to certain audiences, or a number of other reasons

mei-holds-down-yuzu.jpg

Note: If you are in a relationship that is physically or verbally abusive, please seek professional help or consider getting couple’s counseling

The heighten aggression wasn’t a good move in my opinion, and I can understand why a lot of people got so upset. But it is more complicated than that. Mei’s character is complex, and she doesn’t know how to properly interact with people, which causes her to be aggressive at times. My friend OtakuGamerGirlT explains Mei’s character in more depth and why you shouldn’t assume Citrus is all about sexual assault in her  blog post Lesbian Rape? Hardly. Why The First Episode of Citrus Shouldn’t Be Taken At Face Value. Please check it; please explains it perfectly 🙂

As the series goes on, the assault is never quite as dramatic as that first episode. However, it does continue throughout the series to some degree. It’s natural that Mei would continue to be aggressive because she is still learning how to act around people. Also, because she didn’t have parents around, no one told her that the behavior was wrong.

But there were some moments that weren’t needed. There is no need for Mei to attack Yuzu is the bathroom. And the worst, in my opinion, is when Yuzu and Mei are on the train, and Yuzu licks Mei’s ear. I honestly thought that was really stupid and unrealistic (I thought the same thing when I read the manga). The same message- that Mei feels sexual tension around Yuzu- could have been sent without any ear-licking.

Matsuri and Mei fight

Other times, different characters, like Himeko and Matsuri, are sexually aggressive. Again, I think it was exaggerated in the anime compared to the manga. In general, these scenes aren’t really needed. Himeko could have tried to kiss Mei or hit on her without getting all handsy. There was also no need for Matsuri to sexually assault Mei, though it is a little more believable considering her questionable personality.

Overall, I think some of the aggressive scenes were important to the story. Mei’s first kissing attack is a catalyst for Yuzu and her feelings. Himeko hitting on Mei inspired Yuzu to act more on her feelings. Matsuri is absolutely conniving and tested Mei and Yuzu’s feelings for each other. But the truth is… those scenes didn’t have to be so aggressive and sexual. Others, like the ear-licking, could have been taken out all together.

Again, it is understandable if you did not like the sexual scenes because some of them are unnecessary. However, Citrus isn’t like other ecchi anime that just use sex as a gimmick.  Underneath it all, it is about two girls that need to find themselves. It is just cloaked in a veil of drama.

My Verdict: I Am Still A Fan

Despite its shortcomings, I am a big fan of Citrus. It isn’t some meaningless incest show that is rifled with constant fan service. Yes, Yuzu and Mei are step-sisters, but in the end, the sister thing isn’t that important- it’s just what forced them together in the beginning. Yes, they are unneeded sexual scenes, but it is nothing compared to some shows (*cough* Valkyrie Drive Mermaid *cough*).

But overall, Citrus is a story about two girls who are both train wrecks-  Yuzu is all over the place, while Mei is cold and insensitive. The two of them need to come together, support each other, and realize their own feelings.

Citrus Ending Art

And as I explained above, the yuri in Citrus is strong and undeterred. It is an essential part of the story- in fact, it is the entire premise. Even with some hurdles along the way, Yuzu never gives up her feelings for Mei, and she never denies her sexuality. She is just so gay. It is so refreshing and so relatable to queer female such as myself.

With less drama and sexual themes, and some tweaks to the plot (okay, a lot of tweaks to the plot), Citrus could be a 10/10. But no matter what you think of it, you can’t deny that it is huge progress for the yuri community, who needs to see more full-fledged legitimate lesbian relationships. More yuri anime have been announced recently, and hopefully they can help spread awareness about female relationships to the Japanese public and the world.

And the Citrus anime, with all its flaws, was one of the first steps.

citrus-anime-very-end.jpg

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Why Everyone Freaked Out Over The Citrus Anime (Including Me)

  1. Richard Ranft says:

    An excellent review. I also enjoyed the show and I think you’re spot on here.

    Before I start, I want to be clear – I do not intend to come across as combative, but sometimes I do anyway. Please take this as my personal thoughts and reasoning on the subject and not as an attack.

    The only thing I dispute is your definition of incest. The entire purpose of making incest taboo is to prevent an increased risk of birth defects due to inbreeding. That is the whole thing. Honestly, same-sex siblings as close as identical twins don’t fall into this at all – they can’t breed, so the point is moot and now purely socio-psychological. There is no biological reason (the original reason for defining the taboo, remember) to object to same-sex consanguineous relationship – just societal. In the context of this story I see it as adding another aspect to their “taboo” relationship, since society is generally unaccepting of same-sex couples even now. However, from a logical standpoint it is not even an issue.

    Same-sex couples always have a 0% chance of birth defects from offspring because they can’t have any. Labeling it “incest” because they’re actual or step-siblings makes no difference; they still can’t have offspring, so birth defect chance is 0%. At that point, it is quite literally just a label. Only heterosexual couples run the risk of inbreeding and therefore broach upon the territory of the original purpose of establishing the incest taboo.

    One study (just one, but there are others):https://www.larasig.com/node/2020

    Like

    • Rai says:

      Thank you, and I find your explanation very, very interesting.

      You are right that the whole incest taboo is societal, and that Yuzu and Mei’s relationship would be even more “taboo” considering they are both female.

      I never thought about what you said regarding homosexuals’ 0% chance of birth defects. That is a really interesting point.

      My question for you is this- recently, some homosexual couples have had children through the 3-parent method. It’s where two eggs are taken from two women (a lesbian couple) and combined with a male sperm; or when two sperm are taken from two men (a gay couple) and combined with one egg. If anyone is this process was related (whether the couple or the donor), would it still be considered incest?

      Like

  2. OG-Man says:

    My memory of the manga is foggy but I do recall Drill Sergeant Pecos “pouncing” on Mei-Tron there as well when she made her move.

    Otherwise the anime’s greatest achievement remains that it made Citrus’ story tolerable by breathing much needed life into it. Even the “pouncing” which I get it turned off detractors but I’ve grown up watch telenovelas/soap operas with my mom so the rough stuff shown here was par for the course. That’s just me. Anyway what mattered most to me is that it looked good and sold well.

    Now the big focus is to support the Kase-san OVA and Bloom Into You anime. Gotta get the message out there that Yuri fans want more 100% Yuri love stories with no strings attached whatsoever.

    I happily consume most yuri and that won’t change but given the choice I would like more “easy to enjoy” Yuri love stories getting anime adaptations.

    Like

    • Rai says:

      Yes, I agree the story was a little more tolerable in the anime, and that they did breathe life into it. I agree that the overall quality was really good.

      It’s interesting what you said about telenovelas… I wonder if different cultures perceive that kind of behavior differently. Actually, there really hasn’t been a precedence for stopping sexual assault in Japan. I wonder if that contributes to Citrus’ drama.

      And YES! I do like Citrus, but those two series are more important in terms of representing more realistic, less dramatic yuri. I literally screamed when I heard Bloom Into You was getting an anime. Besides Girl Friends (which still needs an anime >__>) and Morinaga-sensei’s other work, Bloom Into You is my favorite yuri manga. It is so different and doesn’t have all the other strings attached. I love Kase-san too. It is so cute! We need to scream about these two anime from every rooftop.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. mattdoylemedia says:

    In the long run, Citrus having style success will hopefully lead to more Yuri adaptions. I do wish the author hadn’t gone down the step-sister route though. To me, the taboo was unnecessary, and a love story could have been told without it. But hey ho. I don’t think it’s harmed sales any, so I may be in the minority there. The underlying romance is, I’m told, a decent one at least.

    I never really got the concept of assault being a way to potentially target a male audience though. I mean, I know I technically ID as fluid, but neither I nor any male I’ve known has ever seen assault as a positive. It can make sense as a plot point sometimes, yes, but for most people I know it’s a definite no-go area for a protagonist. I have the same issue with so many yaoi series showing relationships with assault as a start point. Honestly, I’ve anyways found the concept of using assault to cater to a male audience to be rather insulting. I should note though that I’m not saying you have personally insulted me here; the line of thinking is a common one, and I’m certain it is a legitimate way that series try to target males, it’s just not a concept I can even come close to understanding.

    Still, I’m hoping for positives to come out of Citrus. I want more sweet Yuri to appear. Yuri with adult characters would be nice too (I still stick by Octave as being the best I’ve read).

    Like

    • Rai says:

      I agree the whole step-sister thing is unnecessary as well. She could have created a similar situation (maybe Mei could have been a family friend or something). But overall, it didn’t harm the sales or the reception THAT much, like you said.

      Maybe I should go back and rephrase that part. I don’t think most guys go around thinking assault is okay, not alone positive or sexy. I agree that the idea of assault catering to males is insulting because most guys are decent human beings. On top of that, I also identify as fluid and sometimes consider my gender to be closer to male.

      However, when I was thinking about the reasons why they exaggerated the assault, the only two things I could think of were: they were trying to make it more dramatic, or they were trying to make it more “sexy” or “trashy.” Because the show is about two girls and already has fan service, they probably assumed a lot of guys would watch it. Which isn’t entirely true (A LOT of girls watched it), but I digress.

      But in goods news, more sweet yuri is coming down the road, if you weren’t aware 🙂 Kase-san and Bloom Into You announced anime adaptions! Both are sweet and heartwarming stories about girls in love.

      If you want to enjoy some yuri about adults, I recommend these three manga:

      -Collectors (Sooo good, and one of my favorites. But it is only available online)
      -Lily Love (has a limited English release. About two girls in college)
      -After Lights (just got an English manga translation from Viz! :3)

      Liked by 1 person

      • mattdoylemedia says:

        Yeah, I do think youre right that they were likely trying to make it more trashy. I think my own wording was slightly off though, as I didn’t mean that I thought that you thought it was a suitable way to target a male audience, just that it is a way of thinking that’s quite common. It’s like when you have a show for teens and below with random scantily clad women in and the scene in question is deemed ‘something for the dads’. Uh. That annoys me so much. Still, i’m glad i’m not the onyl fluid person 🙂

        Bloom Into You I’ve heard good things about, so i’m looking forward to that adaption. And thank you for the recommendations! I was jsut looking up After Hours and that sounds quite good. I like the look of Collectors too. It seems familiar, so i’m wondering if I’ve stumbled upon some scans before. Lily Love is entirely new to me though.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s